“…and then I told him to fuck off, obviously! I’m not going to let anyone question my intellectual and scientific integrity like that without saying something right back at them. Some rightful questioning given the circumstances of the find? Expected, welcome even. But anything further than that, especially in an accusatory fashion? Hell no!”
“Damn, I didn’t think the field of speculative revivigenics could get so heated.”
“Meh, I’m not even that surprised. The application of speculative revivigenics to paleontology is always sure to ruffle some feathers. People questioning the accurateness of environmental reconstructions and their long-term environmental impacts over the biospheres they are reintegrated within. You know, stuff of that sort…”
“But isn’t it like, something you already factor in with your research and reconstructions?”
“Well, yes! But still, they question the truthfullness of our simulations and the predictions we draw from them. Like, NO, Adrazandar, we don’t need an entire reconstruction of the planetary surface and their geobiological data if the species we mean to reconstruct literally lived on an isolated island in the middle of the world’s largest ocean.”
“And to think that even I can understand why that is…”
“Doesn’t take much to be smarter than they are.”
“Then let us make a toast, to celebrate our relative and easily obtained un-stupidity.”
“Ahah, you’re just about the worst.”
“Your favorite worst, if I’m not mistaken.”
The two baering clinked their clay mugs, chittering jovially as they drank their sweet hidrgrass tea, surrounded by the smell and whispy streaks of zibirmrian incense. Some moments of serene quiet followed, as one of them looked towards the yellow-green mountains beyond the large panes of elaborately-cut quartz glass.
“So… I know we haven’t really talked about it yet, but what’s your opinion on what’s been going on this past year, politically speaking? You know, with the Confluence as a whole going out of its way to contact other civs in the rest of the galaxy. Bit of a divisive topic, given what I’ve seen in the 'Cosm to far, but I still wanted to pick your brain on the matter.”
“Well it’s uhm… certainly complicated, at least in my mind. On the one hand, I do trust the judgement of the Sequence and consider it a rather positive development for our societies. New cultures, new ideas, new species even: what’s not to love about that? And in a sense, some may even consider it our responsibility to reach out and help whoever and whenever we can. It is, after all, what we did for most of our history, up until some two centuries ago with the trrarrusians.”
“…but…?”
“But, on the other hand these civs are all kind of worse, this time! I don’t really know how to explain it, it’s just that… don’t they all seem to be so different than most of our Kin were before joining the Confluence?”
“Oh yeah, definitely. Like, sure, first contact with the Tihumuuh and the Peehhpep certainly wasn’t particularly amicable, but they still had internal attitudes that were more or less compatible with our own. And distrusting though they were, even the Trrarrusians came around in a pinch and without much need for further recourse. This time though… I just don’t know. Their attitude towards all forms of genetic engineering and morphological freedom alone is very concerning…”
“To then not say anything about their views and beliefs on digital artificial intelligence!”
“Yeah that’s… that’s just an even worse problem. The Treecuu and the Republic are more or less “promising”, but even they just continue to mess up that part.”
“Among other things…”
“Maybe the Alvirans will prove themselves to be a little better. From what I’ve scanned through so far, they don’t seem to be either xenophobic or AIophobic, at least not particularly so. Though we haven’t truly interacted with them enough to make judgments yet, on account of the Confluence being involved in the Otmoonan War and other diplomatic issues.”
“God, don’t even get me started on the war.”
“You think we shouldn’t have been involved?”
“No, no, I definitely agree with our participation, it’s just that the nature of the conflict and our ethical responsibility to get involved in it in the first place is the perfect example of my - well, our - concerns! I mean… slavery?! As an interstellar society?! The persistence of scarcity and unequitable resource distribution systems is already baffling to me considering the nature of these civilizations, but SLAVERY??? The morality of all that is ineffably horrid enough as it is, but the fact that there is no pratical and economical reasoning behind it somehow makes it all worse.”
“I’ve had previous discussions about the Pentarchy before - some even with a couple of teetacs that were visiting Ventari’s Pride some months ago - and I’m pretty sure they rely entirely on ideological and religious reasons for continuining slavery and related practices. A large portion of their factories is in fact automated, but nearly all of them include some part of the production process that is assigned to slaves. Typically something tedious but also not sensitive or truly important, like working in foundries and the more dangerous locations of refinery plants.”
“It’s pathetic, really.”
“What more could one expect from such a breed of society, after all.”
“Otmoonans aside, overall I’m just worried that we’re trying to bite off more than we can ever hope to chew. I’ll admit very clearly that I’m certainly not against the idea of forcefully imposing ourselves over some of these civs - an objective improvement to societies that have had centuries or millennia to properly establish themselves: that would be a good and effective course of action if there were only a few bad apples, mere statistical improbabilities. But if we have to face off against a dozen interstellar polities just in our own backyard, then I doubt that it’d be a viable strategy.”
“And yet, would it be ethical to limit our aid, or even do nothing and simply watch the misery go by uneradicated? We both know it wouldn’t be, and I think even our higher leaders are more than aware of that. Sadly, ethical and high-minded principles must sometimes be left behind in favour of real necessities and hazardous constraints.”
“Especially when we turn out to be the statistically improbable ones.”